Insider Leak: Tesla Desperately Swapping Out Exploding Cybertruck Batteries on the Down Low – Why?

Let’s be honest, Tesla’s Cybertruck rollout has been anything but boring (because why would Elon ever let it be anything else?). But in true Tesla fashion, the company might be quietly sweeping some battery “red flags” under the proverbial stainless steel rug. Simply put, reports are surfacing that Tesla has been “proactively” replacing Cybertruck battery packs for months now, but without the fanfare—or transparency—of an official recall. 

(Source: Giphy) 

Instead it’s been more like:  “Oh, you’re here to fix a busted side mirror? Cool. By the way, here’s a brand-new high-voltage battery pack. Don’t worry about it. See you on Twitter!” LOL 

In short, this mysterious plot started to thicken back in September when a Cybertruck owner, Matt Albers, took his vehicle in for routine service. What he thought would be a quick, one-day tune-up turned into a two-week staycation for his truck. The surprise twist? Tesla added a mysterious line item to his service order: “High Voltage Battery Replacement (Cell Side Dent Induced Core Collapse).”

(Source: Clean Technica) 

Which to be real, is not the kind of phrase that makes you sleep easy, especially when your $100K electric tank is involved. When Albers asked what the deal was, Tesla service casually explained that some battery cells made during his truck’s production window might have “side dents” that could short out. “Proactive replacement,” they called it.  Translation: “We don’t want your truck to spontaneously combust, but we’re not going to make a big deal about it either.”

But then fast forward to Christmas week, and another Cybertruck owner shared a similar story. He went in to replace a smashed side mirror (classic garage exit fail) and walked out with a brand new battery pack installed. Again, no warning, no error messages—just Tesla doing Tesla things, quietly swapping out a critical component like it’s no big deal. 

(Source: Motor 1) 

So what’s the big deal with this? Well, here’s where it gets interesting: Tesla hasn’t issued an official recall, which is kind of standard procedure for something like, I don’t know, a battery that could have “core collapse.” Instead, they’re handling it on a case-by-case basis—sort of like a stealth recall but without the regulatory paperwork. 

The affected Cybertrucks seem to be the early production models (delivered between February and July), which makes sense. First-edition anything is basically beta testing for the masses. But the lack of communication is raising eyebrows—and questions. For one, why aren’t they telling owners upfront? I mean it’s almost the same as dropping off your car for an oil change and finding out they replaced the engine “just in case.” 

(Source: Giphy) 

Number two, is how serious is this “side dent” issue? Of course, Tesla says it’s proactive, but are we talking minor inconvenience or potential fire hazard? And most notably, why in the hell is there no NHSTA filing?  If this were Ford or GM, you better believe there’d be a formal recall with a press release, a hotline, and probably a poorly edited apology video.

Now to be fair, Tesla pulling stunts like this isn’t exactly new. Over-the-air updates have blurred the lines between software fixes and recalls, and the company has a long history of handling issues in-house to avoid bad press. But this feels different. This is hardware—expensive, mission-critical hardware—and it raises questions about transparency and accountability. If the batteries have a legitimate defect, why not just rip the Band-Aid off and file an official recall? But then again, this is just a testament to how Tesla rolls. Love them or hate them, Tesla does things differently—sometimes to their benefit, sometimes not. 

(Source: Giphy) 

Plus, considering the Cybertruck’s launch has already been a rollercoaster, it’s clear the last thing Tesla needs is more bad press. Meaning, if you’re one of the lucky few driving a Cybertruck, keep an eye on your service receipts. If Tesla decides to gift you a new battery pack out of nowhere, maybe ask a few follow-up questions.

But for the rest of us investors, this is yet another reminder that Tesla plays by its own rules. Whether that’s genius or reckless depends on your perspective—and possibly your stock portfolio. So yeah, in the meantime, keep an eye on this story as it develops. Maybe Tesla will give everyone clarity on this issue in the future. Maybe not. But regardless, Elon is going to Elon and once again, we are all left wondering “Why?”. 

As always, do what you will with this information and stay safe and stay frosty, friends! Until next time…

P.S. Not to brag (okay, maybe just a little), but we just ranked #23 for free News Apps, beating The Washington Post, CNN, MSNBC, Bloomberg, and more. 🎉 If you want full access to our trading tools (including our "Insider Trade Tracker" to see where the smart money is moving in real time) just become a Stocks.News premium member. Ironically, it costs way less than a Bloomberg subscription. Or hey, no pressure… keep enjoying our articles as a free member. 

Stocks.News holds positions in Tesla and Ford as mentioned in the article.